News Summary
A significant historic Victorian home, the Poyntz-O’Neal House, is listed for $3.75 million in Orlando. Originally built in 1884, the residence has been extensively restored and features stunning 19th-century millwork, multiple fireplaces, and modern amenities. Spanning 6,261 square feet, it includes five bedrooms, four bathrooms, and a guest house on a large downtown plot. The home holds historical significance, hosting early women’s voting rights meetings and being part of the Lake Cherokee Historic District.
Orlando
A historic Victorian home located on Lake Cherokee has been put on the market for $3.75 million. Known as the Poyntz-O’Neal House, this significant dwelling is the last remaining residence from the former Honeymoon Row, a landmark area, and was originally constructed in 1884.
The current listing agent, Tom Buitenhuis, co-owner of the property along with his husband, has undertaken extensive restoration work to bring the house back to its original 1880s magnificence since purchasing it in 2022. The home spans 6,261 square feet and includes five bedrooms and four bathrooms.
This elegant home preserves much of its original 19th-century millwork, including intricate pocket doors and original flooring that reflect the era’s craftsmanship. Notable features of the house include clawfoot tubs, a grand staircase complemented by a smaller servant staircase, and eight fireplaces that, while non-functional, boast original tiling that narrates different stories of the past. Additionally, the residence houses a non-working elevator, reportedly one of the oldest in Orlando.
The property is situated just half a mile from cultural hubs such as the Dr. Phillips Center for the Performing Arts and Lake Eola Park, enhancing its appeal.
Historical Significance
Honeymoon Row earned its name in the 1880s, when homes were constructed for newly married couples. The Poyntz-O’Neal House was originally built by Oliver and Matilda Poyntz, and later became associated with William Russel O’Neal, a notable businessman and politician.
This home has historical significance beyond its architecture; it hosted the first meeting for women’s voting rights in Central Florida within its parlor, marking a key moment in local history. In the 1970s, this valuable structure faced the threat of demolition, but a community effort came to its rescue when 12 families collectively purchased the house to preserve it. This act was pivotal in establishing the Lake Cherokee Historic District, which received official recognition in 1981. The house was designated as a local landmark in 1977.
Modern Appeal
The property extends over 0.59 acres, making it one of the largest residential plots in downtown Orlando. It features beautifully landscaped gardens, a pool, and a koi pond, which adds to the tranquil ambience of the surroundings. The sale also includes a renovated one-bedroom, one-bath guest house, providing additional living options.
Buitenhuis emphasizes the importance of maintaining the historical integrity of the home while incorporating modern updates, ensuring it remains functional for contemporary living. The decision to sell comes as a result of space considerations for the couple, who hope to find a buyer who values the charm and history of older homes. Their emotional attachment to the property is evident, as it has been a dedicated passion project for both owners.
This listing presents a unique opportunity for potential buyers to own a piece of Orlando’s history while enjoying the luxuries of modern amenities and a prime location.
Deeper Dive: News & Info About This Topic
HERE Resources
Fort Myers Recovers as Premier Tourist Destination
Orlando’s Magical Dining Marks 20th Anniversary with Record Attendance
Kerr County’s Tragic Flooding: The Latest Updates
Trump Proposes Reviving Alcatraz as a Maximum-Security Prison
Disney On Ice Announces New Touring Shows
UCF Welcomes New Transfer Player to Softball Team
Universities Explore Space-Themed Football Rivalry
Dr. Phillips Charities Breaks Ground on New Office Building in Orlando
National Parks Celebrate Record Visitor Numbers
Lightning Strike Ignites Fire at Unoccupied Orlando Home
Additional Resources
- Orlando Sentinel: Magnificent Queen Anne Victorian on Honeymoon Row Hits the Market
- Orlando Weekly: Historic Downtown Orlando Townhome for Sale
- Visit Orlando: Orlando History Blog
- Orlando Weekly: Downtown Orlando Mid-Century Modern Home
- Click Orlando: Most Haunted Spots in Orlando
- Wikipedia: Orlando
- Google Search: Orlando Florida
- Google Scholar: Orlando History
- Encyclopedia Britannica: Orlando
- Google News: Orlando Real Estate
